🍗 Feast Mode
Thanksgiving is just two weeks away. How did that happen?
It’s worth knowing that, if you want them, teams of New Haven chefs and bakers now stand at the ready, waiting to shoulder all or part of the load via pre-order entrées, sides, desserts and more.
But it turns out it’s heavy lifting just to figure out what your options are. So here’s a menu of all the special holiday pre-order menus we could find, with light summaries, helpful links and crucial deadlines:
Anthony’s Ocean View (New Haven)
Order by Nov. 20. Pickup Nov. 25.
Complete turkey dinner with stuffing, baked ziti, sides and pie ($285).
Atticus Market (New Haven)
Order at least 48 hours ahead. Pickup on selected date.
Apple and pumpkin pies ($37.50) and sweet potato pull-apart bread ($10).
Auntie MoMo’s Bakery (East Haven)
Order online. Pickup Nov. 25, 10 a.m.–7 p.m.
Gluten-free mini pies, dinner rolls, cinnamon rolls and pumpkin treats, with vegan options.
baked on ALLEN (North Haven)
Order by Nov. 18, 3 p.m. Pickup Nov. 25 after 4 p.m.
Bread flights, cinnamon rolls, sandwich loaves, dinner rolls and crumb cakes. Text 203-623-2994.
Baking Fairy Boutique (New Haven)
Order by Nov. 18, 5 p.m. Pickup Nov. 25.
Thanksgiving sheet cakes in pumpkin caramel, Biscoff, strawberry crunch and other flavors ($85–$95).
Bear’s Smokehouse BBQ (New Haven)
Order by Nov. 22. Cold pickup Nov. 25; hot pickup Nov. 26.
Whole smoked turkeys ($110) and complete feasts for six to eight ($225).
Bishop’s Orchards (Guilford)
Order turkeys by Nov. 16; pies and sides by Nov. 22. Pickup Nov. 24–25, 7 a.m.–7 p.m.
Fresh turkeys, prepared meals, traditional sides and more than 10 varieties of pie.
Bite Back Bakehouse (West Haven)
Order online. Pickup by appointment.
Thanksgiving cookie assortments in boxes of six ($20), 10 ($36) or 24 ($72).
Bread & Batter (North Haven)
Order by Nov. 23. Pickup Nov. 25 by arrangement.
Sourdough, dinner rolls, bagels, cornbread, scones and coffee cakes (from $8).
Bridge House Restaurant (Milford)
Order ahead; call for deadline. Pickup Nov. 25 after 2 p.m.
Heat-and-eat turkey dinners for four ($160), eight to 12 ($350) or 15–20 ($479).
Café Amici (Hamden)
Order ahead; call for deadline. Pickup Nov. 25, noon–3 p.m.
Turkey dinner for six with traditional sides, salad, bread and cheesecake ($225).
Claire’s Corner Copia (New Haven)
Order by Nov. 24. Pickup Nov. 25.
Three-course Thanksgiving meals ($25/person) with a choice of entrée, two sides and dessert. Vegetarian, vegan and gluten-free options.
The Copper Whisk (Branford)
Order by Nov. 19. Pickup Nov. 25, 3–7 p.m.
Apple crumb pies, dinner rolls, cinnamon rolls, scones and breads.
Downright Breads (West Haven/New Haven)
Order by Nov. 21. Pickup Nov. 24–25, 10 a.m.–5 p.m.
Cranberry pecan, pumpkin sage and decorative pumpkin-shaped sourdough loaves.
East Rock Breads (New Haven)
Order online. Pickup Nov. 25, 10 a.m.–4 p.m.
Apple crumb and pumpkin pies ($35), caramel nut tarts ($24), and dinner rolls ($12).
Eli’s Restaurant Group (Hamden/Branford)
Order by Nov. 20. Pickup Nov. 25.
Turkey breast with stuffing, mashed potatoes, green beans and gravy, plus sides and pies.
Five Roosters Gluten-Free Bakery (North Branford)
Order by Nov. 22, 8 p.m. Pickup by appointment.
Gluten-free fruit pies ($25), hand pies, breads, rolls and cookies.
The Fresh Market (Guilford)
Order by Nov. 24, 2 p.m. Pickup Nov. 23–26.
Prepared turkey, ham and prime rib dinners, sides, desserts and brunch kits.
Funky Farmstand (Northford)
Order by Nov. 18, 8 p.m. Pickup Nov. 25, 10 a.m.–1 p.m.
Sourdough, cinnamon rolls, pumpkin bread, coffee cakes and bread flights ($28).
G Café Bakery (New Haven/Branford)
Order by Nov. 23. Pickup Nov. 25 before 2 p.m.
Apple ($38) and spiced pumpkin ($40) pies, almond Gateau Basque ($38), Linzer torte ($35), gluten-free chocolate tart ($45) and Basque cheesecakes ($54).
Gioia Café & Bar (New Haven)
Order by Nov. 21, 6 p.m. Pickup Nov. 24–25, noon–5:30 p.m.
Chocolate pecan, apple crumble and brown-butter pumpkin pies ($40); vanilla gelato ($10).
Heirloom Restaurant (New Haven)
Order by Nov. 20. Pickup Nov. 26.
Cider-brined turkey dinner for two with stuffing, vegetables, rolls and pie ($90).
Joseph’s on Whitney by Chef Mickey (North Haven)
Order by Nov. 21. Pickup Nov. 25 or 26.
Turkey dinner for 10–12 with soup, stuffing, potatoes, vegetables and rolls ($299 Wednesday; $349 Thursday).
Linda’s Delicious Treats (New Haven)
Order by Nov. 19, 6 p.m. Pickup Nov. 25 by arrangement.
Thanksgiving sweets and desserts. Call or text 475-224-8299 for the menu.
Malby Artisan Bread & Pastries (New Haven)
Order by Nov. 22. Pickup Nov. 26 before noon.
Pumpkin pie ($32), pecan tart ($36), sourdough apple cake ($38) and dinner rolls ($10).
Marjolaine Pastry Shop (New Haven)
Order by phone. Pickup through Nov. 25; limited slots.
Fruit and cream pies, pumpkin Cognac cheesecake, cakes and tea breads. Call 203-789-8589.
Monty’s River Grille (Milford)
Order by Nov. 19, noon. Pickup Nov. 25, noon–4 p.m.
Turkey dinner for eight to 10 with stuffing, potatoes, vegetables, cranberry relish and pie.
Nonna Gina’s Prepared Foods (Branford)
Order by Nov. 21, 5 p.m. Pickup Nov. 25, 10 a.m.–3 p.m.
Antipasto, arancini, stuffed breads, pasta, salads and Italian holiday sides.
P&M Orange Street Market (New Haven)
Pre-order by phone or Instagram DM.
Roasted turkey breast dinners for two, four or eight with gravy, two to four sides and bread ($44.95–$159.95), plus seven varieties of pie. Call 203-865-1147.
Petonito’s Pastry Shoppe (East Haven)
Order early. Pickup Nov. 24, 8:30 a.m.–5 p.m., or Nov. 25, 8:30 a.m.–7 p.m.
Apple, pumpkin and pecan pies ($23), plus cannoli, cupcakes and cookies. Call 203-469-1817.
Provisions on State (New Haven)
Reserve early. Pickup Nov. 22–25.
Farm-raised whole turkeys and bone-in breasts, including heritage breeds ($75 deposit).
ROLi Cuisine + Libations (New Haven)
Order by Nov. 19. Pickup Nov. 25, 3–5 p.m.
Turkey dinners with stuffing, gravy, Brussels sprouts, sweet potatoes and soup (from $110 for two).
Sandra’s Next Generation (New Haven)
Order and pay by Nov. 20. Pickup Nov. 25.
Fried or baked turkeys (from $90), Cajun preparations, seafood mac and cheese, sides and desserts.
Scratch Baking (Milford)
Order online. Pickup Nov. 24–25.
Apple, pumpkin and pecan pies, caramel apple cheesecake pie, cakes, quiches and breads.
Sherkaan Indian Street Food (New Haven)
Order by Nov. 21. Pickup Nov. 25 at noon, 2, 4 or 6 p.m.
Indian-style Friendsgiving feasts for four or eight, plus à la carte dishes.
Thyme & Season Natural Market (Hamden)
Order by Nov. 20. Pickup Nov. 24–25.
Turkey dinners ($25.99), vegan dinners ($22.99), sides, catering and fresh turkeys.
Widow's Son Lodge No. 1 (New Haven)
Order by Nov. 19. Pickup Nov. 26, 7 a.m.–noon.
Fried turkeys, $60 for 13–15 pounds or $75 for 20–22 pounds. Call 203-214-7078.
And with that, let us all give thanks for the option, if we want it, to make our Thanksgivings a little (or a lot) easier—and hopefully even tastier, too.
Written by Daily Nutmeg Staff. Readers are encouraged to verify availability and pricing before purchasing—and to place any orders ASAP.
Keep reading Daily Nutmeg
Get the rest of this story, plus the best of New Haven in your inbox each weekday.
You're in! Enjoy the rest of the story.