🍕 Apizza Apop-up

🍕 Apizza Apop-up

New Haven’s newest pizza attraction doesn’t have an oven, but it still serves up pizza-themed clothing, accessories, artwork, artifacts, and all sorts of curiosities at a new holiday pop-up shop at 1090 Chapel Street.

The storefront is a collaboration between Campus Customs’ Jeremy Cobden and New Haven Pizza Club’s Michael Pollack, who created much of the artwork and installations (including two pizza thrones). Two years after Daily Nutmeg profiled Cobden and his family’s longtime New Haven business, we caught up with him about the new venture.

Where did the idea for all of this come from?

During COVID, when our retail store was shut down, a friend and I started playing around with pizza designs. We all grew up on New Haven pizza. We’d always carried some New Haven and pizza merchandise, but we started conceptualizing fun shirts that we could sell online through Pizza Life New Haven.

When the store reopened, I created a little section in the back for those products.

Then Michael and I connected. He was doing a fashion show and needed merchandise, and we started collaborating on designs. Eventually, we were approached about doing this store together, and it seemed like a natural fit.

You already sell pizza merchandise on Broadway. Why open a second shop on Chapel Street?

I’ve been looking for opportunities to do a holiday pop-up for a couple of years. Anytime there’s a vacancy, I think about what could go there.

Broadway and Chapel Street are different markets. People tend to stick to certain areas. My hope is to bring people into this part of the city who might not otherwise come. Pizza is a huge draw, not just for New Haven but for Connecticut. People travel here specifically for it.

And it’s a conversation starter. I can be in Florida or New York, and when people find out I’m from New Haven, they want to talk about pizza.

How much of what we’re seeing here is Michael’s work?

Michael has done a tremendous amount. He worked day and night to get this place ready, and he brought so much of the art and the visual experience into it.

There’s the Christmas tree made from local pizza boxes, the artwork, the different installations. He’s incredibly creative, and I don’t know anybody else who could have made this place look the way it does so quickly.

We want people to spend half an hour in here, walking around, looking at Michael’s artwork and enjoying themselves. It’s not supposed to be just a place where you run in and buy a T-shirt.

And you produced all of this in three weeks?

Pretty much. We printed a couple thousand pieces, with probably 20 or 30 different designs. I’d say at least 12 to 15 of those were created specifically for this store.

Everything was printed in our building here in New Haven. People don’t always realize we do all that work ourselves. We’re in the old York Square Cinema building, and we have full screen-printing operations and 21 embroidery heads.

There’s a tremendous amount of work that goes into a garment. You’ve got the printing, the embroidery, the neck labels, the tagging. Some pieces probably pass through 10 different people’s hands before they’re finished.

My staff worked tirelessly. Michael worked day and night. It was a real team effort.

And what’s for sale, besides T-shirts?

We’ve got hats, sweatshirts, framed artwork, prints, custom sneakers, espresso cups. Almost everything in the store is for sale.

The T-shirts start at $20, and we’ve got more premium pieces. One of my favorites is an embroidered piece that’s $60. It took a lot of work from our staff to get the embroidery right.

The custom sneakers are $250. We’ve got prints for $20, and framed artwork starting around $250.

My goal is to have something for everybody. It’s meant to be a fun store, and I want people to be able to find something at a price point that works for them.

The merchandise has a pretty wide-ranging aesthetic. There’s retro advertising, streetwear, music and sports. How did you settle on the designs?

It’s a mix of our interests. We grew up in the ’90s, and unfortunately the ’90s are retro now.

But we’ve tried to bring in things from the ’60s, ’70s and ’80s too. New Haven has a wide range of people. You’ve got college students who might not know anything about the ’90s, and then you’ve got people like my father, who grew up with a completely different culture.

We’re trying to create something for everyone. Some of it has a tourist feel, some of it is nostalgic, and some of it is just fun.

And the designs will evolve. We have more in the works. We’re going to find out what people respond to and build on that.

You’ve said nostalgia a few times now...

New Haven is a very nostalgic town. You see it on Facebook all the time. People remembering old restaurants, old stores, things that used to be here.

Pizza is a big part of that for me.

Michael and I didn’t know each other when we were younger, but we both went to the Colony Beach Club. Once a year, my parents would bring Sally’s pizza there, and it was a huge deal. Getting Sally’s wasn’t easy in those days, and bringing it out to the beach club was a special occasion.

It turns out Michael had similar experiences there. We didn’t know each other then, but we have those shared memories.

So when I see Sally’s, I remember being a kid. When I go into Ernie’s, I get a certain feeling. You get that at Sally’s, at Pepe’s, at Modern. There’s history there. You can’t just open a restaurant and create that overnight.

I’d love for this store to evolve beyond celebrating our greatest food and start capturing some of that other New Haven nostalgia too.

Speaking of Ernie’s, you told me that’s your favorite. What’s your order?

Ernie’s is my favorite because I grew up eating there. Pat makes broccoli rabe better than anybody. Nobody makes it like he does.

But I also love sauce, so I have to get a pepperoni and olive. I need a red and a white.

I eat a lot of pizza.

What’s the hardest part of running a retail business today?

Getting people in the door.

Online shopping has changed everything. There are so many options now. We have a strong online business ourselves, so I understand that.

But I think every retail business has a responsibility to create a reason for someone to come inside.

You can’t go online and see a Christmas tree made out of local pizza boxes that Michael built. You can’t experience the artwork and the atmosphere in the same way.

That’s what we’re trying to do here. Give people something to experience, not just something to buy.

And what would make the pop-up a success in your eyes?

I want people to come downtown. That’s really what it comes down to.

If somebody comes here because they’re a fan of a pizza place, that’s great. Maybe they’ll shop here and then go to dinner somewhere in New Haven. Maybe somebody who shops here will go try a pizza place they haven’t been to before.

This is a vibrant city, and there are so many reasons to visit. The more people who come here and decide to spend some time, the better.

That’s what I’m hoping this helps accomplish.

The Campus Customs and New Haven Pizza Club holiday pop-up is at 1090 Chapel Street, New Haven, next to Atticus Bookstore Café. The shop is expected to remain open through December.

 

Written and photographed by Daily Nutmeg Staff.

More Stories

Become a Daily Nutmeg Member!

Daily Nutmeg Members get exclusive access to The Chaser, a drink and appetizer passport with complimentary offers to 13 of New Haven's favorite bars and restaurants.

Join today!